2023’s Most Sustainable Cities

An engineer observes a row of solar panels and wind turbines in a grassy area.

Which American cities are leading the way toward a sustainable future, and which ones are lagging behind?

Find out in our ranking of 2023’s Most Sustainable Cities.

To mark Earth Day on April 22, LawnStarter compared the 200 biggest U.S. cities based on five sustainability categories. We looked at the number of zero-energy buildings, alternative fuel stations, and greenhouse-gas emissions, among 26 total metrics.

See how your city compares below. To learn how we ranked the cities, see our methodology.

Contents

City Rankings + Infographic

See how each city fared in our ranking:

Infographic showing the Most Sustainable Cities, a ranking based on the number of zero-energy buildings, alternative fuel stations, greenhouse-gas emissions, and more
Note: For presentation purposes, not all ties may be displayed for some metrics above.

Top 5 Close Up

Check out the slideshow below for highlights and lowlights on each of our top five cities.

A woman reads a book on a grassy hill overlooking the historic painted ladies and greater San Francisco skyline.
No. 1: San Francisco | Overall Score: 77.21

Policy: 5
Sustainable Development: 1
Pollution: 77
Transportation: 2
Food Production: 16

Local tips: In 2007, San Francisco became the first American city to ban plastic bags, and has since banned the sale of plastic bottles on city-owned properties. According to the 2021 San Francisco Climate Action Plan, the city is striving to have net-zero emissions by 2040. San Francisco is also working toward reducing waste and currently diverts 80% of its trash from landfills to recycling and composting programs.

Photo Credit: Juan Salamanca / Pexels / Pexels License
Lights glow from high-rise buildings on a wintery night in Boston.
No. 2: Boston | Overall Score: 71.57

Policy: 7
Sustainable Development: 6
Pollution: 92
Transportation: 3
Food Production: 1

Local tips: Boston met and exceeded its 2020 carbon reduction goal, and is planning to be carbon-neutral by 2050. In 2018, Boston implemented a plastic bag ordinance and is currently working to become a zero-waste city, with a 2030 goal of 80-90% trash diversion from landfills by reducing, reusing, recycling, and composting. 

Photo Credit: Nate Hovee / Pexels / Pexels License
Skyline Photo of Empire State Building in New York City
No. 3: New York | Overall Score: 70.68

Policy: 1
Sustainable Development: 11
Pollution: 164
Transportation: 1
Food Production: 89

Local tips: The NYC Carbon Challenge has so far saved $200 million in energy costs, and reduced participants’ annual emissions by over 600,000 metric tons. New York is hoping to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050. Plan an eco-vacation to NYC and visit one of the city’s many farm-to-table restaurants or green attractions

Photo Credit: Roberto Vivancos / Pexels / Pexels License
Streets of high-rise buildings make up Oakland’s skyline on an overcast day.
No. 4: Oakland, California | Overall Score: 69.36

Policy: 4
Sustainable Development: 8
Pollution: 57
Transportation: 14
Food Production: 39

Local tips: From green dining to zero-emission vehicles to building sustainable housing with the help of mushrooms, Oakland residents are at the forefront of living sustainably. Oakland is also home to 2023’s most sustainable American company, and the first carbon-neutral healthcare system in the nation. 

Photo Credit: James BeBop / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0
Boats float while docked at the marina at sunset, with the San Diego skyline glittering in the background.
No. 5: San Diego | Overall Score: 66.56

Policy: 18
Sustainable Development: 2
Pollution: 104
Transportation: 19
Food Production: 56

Local tips: With plenty of gorgeous natural space to explore in and around the city, and plenty of options for thrifting and green dining, it’s not hard to believe that San Diegans value the environment. San Diego decreased emissions by 25% between 2010 and 2020, and is planning to achieve net-zero emissions by 2035

Photo Credit: Lucas Fonseca / Pexels / Pexels License

Key Insights

The Green Gist

Sustainable policies are being implemented in cities across the nation. Today, 60 out of the 200 biggest U.S. cities we ranked support urban heat island mitigation programs, 85 boast local clean city coalitions, and 90 are members of Local Governments for Sustainability (ICLEI). On the downside, in recent years, more than half of the biggest U.S. cities have had drinking water quality violations.

California leads the way in green living, with 25 cities landing in the top half of our ranking — six in the top 10.

Southern suburbs like Texas cities Grand Prairie (No. 198) and Pasadena (No. 199) sank to the bottom of our ranking, alongside Mesquite, in last place. This is due to a car-dependent infrastructure, lack of zero-energy buildings and eco-friendly policies, and green amenities like alternative-fuel stations.

Standout Sustainability Stats

  • Golden City: Bringing home the gold star overall, San Francisco takes first place in Sustainable Development with the best access to alternative-fuel stations, nearly 11 per square mile. San Francisco also is the most bike-friendly and the best for living car-free.
  • Acing Green Architecture: Sustainable San Diego (No. 5) retains the most zero-energy buildings, followed by Sacramento (No. 9), Los Angeles (No. 10), and San Francisco (No. 1). San Diego also takes third place in self-sustainable housing-friendliness, behind LA and San Francisco.
  • Eco-Forward Infrastructure: Driving toward becoming the nation’s electric car capital by 2030 is San Jose (No. 6). The city currently stands at No. 26 in alternative fuel stations per square mile. San Jose also boasts the sixth-best self-sustainable housing-friendliness and is No. 9 in the number of zero-energy buildings.
  • The Big (Green) Apple: With eco-forward incentives and the best transit score, New York (No. 3) rises to first place in both Policy and Transportation. NYC sustains the most Global Green partners and ties with Baltimore (No. 8) for the most incentives and policies supporting renewables and green energy.
  • Getting Around Beantown: It’s easy to lead an eco-minded lifestyle in Boston (No. 2), which dominates in Food Production, with high locavore-friendliness and the second-highest number of green restaurants. Boston also takes third place in Transportation and offers the third-highest number of alternative-fuel stations per square mile.
  • Gas Guzzlers: Wide-open spaces with a car-dependent infrastructure lead to Texas-sized greenhouse-gas emissions. Houston (No. 83) produces the most emissions, and the other major Texas cities aren’t far behind. Houston, Dallas (No. 85), San Antonio (No. 64), Fort Worth (No. 157), and Austin (No. 23) also have some of the highest annual excess fuel consumption per car commuter and high levels of landfill waste per capita.
  • Climate Captains: California cities Oakland (No. 4), Fullerton (No. 54), Stockton (No. 90), and Pomona (No. 137) tie with Virginia Beach, Virginia (No. 53), and Jersey City, New Jersey (No. 79), for the lowest greenhouse-gas emissions. Des Moines, Iowa (No. 36), Fayetteville, North Carolina (No. 133), and Lincoln, Nebraska (No. 96), tie for the lowest annual excess fuel consumption.

Honorable Mentions

  • Seattle (No. 7) is ideal for locavores, urban gardeners, and car-free living. The city also possesses the nation’s first carbon-neutral electric utility and is home to the self-proclaimed “world’s greenest commercial building,” the Bullitt Center. The Emerald City also will host the next Greater & Greener conference, which focuses on developing sustainable urban landscapes. 
  • Chicago (No. 13) offers wonderful options for public transit, thrifting, and green dining. City buildings and the Chicago Transit Authority have resolved to implement 100% renewable energy within the next two decades. Chicago also grows more than 5 million square feet of green-roof coverage. 
  • Portland, Oregon (No. 14) has the fifth-highest number of zero-energy buildings and the sixth-best historical median air quality. The City of Roses has been a pioneer of sustainable urban planning in the U.S. for decades and plans to run on 100% renewable energy by 2050.

Ask The Experts

America needs sustainable solutions that stick. Our panel of experts weigh in and share their tips on adopting a more eco-friendly lifestyle. Read their thoughts below.

  1. What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years?
  2. What are your top three tips for green living?
  3. Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?
Sossina M. Haile
Walter P. Murphy Professor of Materials Science and Engineering
Pankaj Lal, PhD
Director, Clean Energy and Sustainability Analytics Center, Professor, Earth & Environmental Studies
Jan Kleissl
Director, Center for Energy Research, Co-Director, Study Abroad, Deputy Editor, Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy, Professor, Department of Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering
John Harte
Professor of the Graduate School, Ecosystem Sciences, ERG/ESPM
Rajesh Sharma
Associate Professor
Ximing Cai
Colonel Harry F. and Frankie M. Lovell Endowed Professor in Civil Engineering
Bradley Edward Layton, PhD PE
Founder, Human Powered Future PLLC, Affiliated Faculty
Sossina M. Haile
Walter P. Murphy Professor of Materials Science and Engineering
Northwestern University

What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years?

Ideas that teach the general public that sustainable matters and it’s not all some hoax made up by scientists who want their research funded. Once we get past that, it will be the idea that we should live in “integrated” neighborhoods in which we can maintain our daily lives without having to commute long distances in single-occupancy vehicles.

What are your top three tips for green living?

  1. Live close enough to work and shopping that you can walk or bike.
  2. Avoid eating meat.
  3. Buy second-hand items when you can (I find this the hardest).

Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?

U.S. cities have been designed with the car in mind. We would need wholesale redesign of cities like Los Angeles and Houston to make mass transit effective. With political will, we could do it, but that requires a true appreciation for the magnitude of the calamity that awaits us if we don’t.

Pankaj Lal, PhD
Director, Clean Energy and Sustainability Analytics Center, Professor, Earth & Environmental Studies
Montclair State University

What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years?

  • Investments in carbon capture and storage, green infrastructure, renewable energy technology, energy storage technologies, electric vehicle deployment infrastructure mass transit upgrades, energy-efficient buildings, and land conservancy, and habitat restoration
  • Appropriating funds to advancing science and research, as well as programs aimed at informing the public on environmental concerns and sustainable practices
  • Energy-efficiency technologies will make a huge impact on global emissions. By transitioning to clean energy (like wind, solar, etc.) we can reduce industry and household carbon footprints substantially. As energy-efficiency technology continues to gain popularity, there is incentive to continuously improve efficiency, which in turn makes these technologies more affordable and accessible globally.
  • Reforming environmental policy and ensuring equitable access to the proposed sustainable development.

What are your top three tips for green living?

  • Prioritize sustainability over convenience. This can be done in many ways in your day-to-day life. Purchase and use consumable goods thoughtfully to reduce waste, reduce energy consumption in your home, limit personal vehicle use where possible, and, when upgrading appliances or vehicles, make energy efficiency a priority.
  • Support businesses that are prioritizing the environment. Do your research on the companies you choose to support via purchases and choose those that are being managed responsibly. Businesses are partially consumer-driven, when consumers demand sustainability, more industry is likely to meet those demands.
  • Find a way to connect with the natural environment. Whether this be through hiking, gardening, visiting farms, etc., being proactive about engaging with the natural world can help make green living easier. When you are enjoying the natural world, you’re more likely to want to preserve it and make responsible earth-friendly decisions.

Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?

Advancements to sustainable transportation in the U.S. is so far behind other countries due to its high costs, lack of investments, and public awareness. Personal vehicles in the U.S. are both a cultural choice and a much-needed asset because of minimal mass transit nationwide! Much of the focus for sustainable transportation has been on improving personal vehicles (via hybrid and electric cars availability and infrastructure), but there is still much to be done for many consumers to buy in.

The way most cities are laid out do not allow for mass transit, and the shear expanse of the country provides challenges that other countries with well-developed mass transit have not had to deal with. To catch up, national collaboration is essential in making cross-country and cross-city travel easier.

Jan Kleissl
Director, Center for Energy Research, Co-Director, Study Abroad, Deputy Editor, Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy, Professor, Department of Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering
University of California-San Diego

What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years?

Flexible loads: With smarter appliances, such as electric vehicles, water heaters, air conditioners, and refrigerators, it will be easier to manage the power grid to provide more economical and reliable energy. At UC San Diego, we are building a large testbed for the communications backbone for the future power grid.

Heat-pump technology for water heating and space heating: Heat pumps allow heating with electricity rather than fossil fuels, and their efficiency is roughly a factor of three times the efficiency of traditional electric resistance heating.

What are your top three tips for green living?

  1. Dense urban living: Living in apartments/condos in dense urban areas dramatically reduces energy use for transportation and space heating/cooling. A condo typically has one or two outside walls that heat up the living space versus six for a single family home. So you get a factor of five or so reduction in cooling needs. Dense urban cores also are more walkable reducing vehicle mileage and improving health.
  2. Induction cooktops: Induction cooking is more efficient, faster, and safer compared to standard electric cooktops.
  3. Behavior: Combine car trips and online orders. Turn the AC off when you are not home. Eat leftovers.

Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?

Low density of living and strong individuality: Low density of living dramatically increases vehicle miles traveled. Large streets, parking lots, single-family homes cause everything to be spread out, making distances to central train stations too large to be attractive to commuters. Americans like to be in control of their schedules and have a fast-paced lifestyle, which is inconsistent with the fixed schedules and slower pace of mass transit.

For those reasons, high-speed trains will never be feasible in the U.S. COVID sent mass transit into a death spiral in all but the densest urban areas such as New York City. The only viable solution in the U.S. are electric cars and scooters, but the former will require a massive investment into the electric grid as car travel is much less efficient than train or bus travel.

John Harte
Professor of the Graduate School, Ecosystem Sciences, ERG/ESPM
University of California-Berkeley

What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years?

  • The idea that small families are desirable, and that all women, everywhere, have the right to exercise freedom over their own reproduction.
  • The idea that green energy is cheaper in the long run than fossil energy, and has multiple benefits that go beyond reducing the threat of climate catastrophe.
  • The idea that regulations and taxes enlarge our freedoms and make our lives better.

What are your top three tips for green living?

  • Walk or bicycle, rather than drive, whenever possible.
  • Avoid buying crap wrapped in plastic.
  • In winter, a room at 60 degrees F plus a sweater is more comfortable and healthier than a room at 65 or 70 degrees F.

Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?

Because a while back, largely under Reagan, a large segment of the the U.S. public bought into the notion that government was bad, regulations are bad, taxes are bad. We lost 40 years because of this. The folly of those notions has to become apparent to people before we can catch up.

Rajesh Sharma
Associate Professor
Arkansas State University

What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years?

Modernizing our electric transmission infrastructure, coupled with renewable power generation (wind and solar) and storage, will have the biggest positive impact on our environment in the near future.

I am also hopeful of breakthroughs in technologies, such as nuclear fusion and renewable hydrogen production, which can have a significant impact on the energy landscape.

What are your top three tips for green living?

  1. Food choices: A vegetarian diet or even cutting down on meat consumption can have a big impact on the environment.
  2. Conserve water: This may not seem like a problem right now, but it could be a challenge in the future.
  3. Energy-efficiency: This should be the proposition; everybody should follow everywhere.

Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?

I don’t think the U.S. should strive to be like other countries in developing sustainable transportation infrastructure. We should look for solutions that are geared toward our specific problems.

That said, we should still look into developing high-speed trains between population centers on the East Coast as well as the West Coast. This may not be the optimal mass-transit solution for the sparsely populated middle part of the county. A self-driving fuel-cell/electric bus may be a better and sustainable mass-transit solution here.

Ximing Cai
Colonel Harry F. and Frankie M. Lovell Endowed Professor in Civil Engineering
University of Illinois-Urbana-Champaign

What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years?

We should promote the circular economy to largely reduce wastes, enhance recycling (i.e. zero waste), and save energy and resources.

Cities, rural communities, and companies should have a designated target of zero carbon emissions in the not-too-distant future, say 2050, by regional-specific portfolio, including increasing renewable-energy generation and use, increasing energy-use efficiency, reducing wastes, controlling vehicle uses, and/or enhancing best management practices in land uses, etc.

What are your top three tips for green living?

1. Everyone should change their behaviors to reduce food and water waste in daily life.

2. Governments and communities should invest in recycling facilities to enable residents to do better at recycling (most communities in the U.S. still do not have the typical three-bin — waste, paper, and can — recycling systems).

3. Residents should be encouraged to adopt rain gardens, green or solar roofs, and geothermal systems; incentives (e.g., additional property tax) may go with house sizes.

Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?

Large-scale new infrastructure development in the U.S. has been difficult. The reason(s) is certainly different from that in poor developing countries. I guess this might be related to the lack of an appropriate benefit/cost assessment approach, especially the benefit/cost share mechanism among multiple stakeholders.

This might also be related to the decision making procedures, which need to better balance human and environmental requirements, coordinate priorities from the various societies, and more effectively resolve conflicts among stakeholders.

Overall, actions are needed today rather than never-ending wait-and-see.

Bradley Edward Layton, PhD PE
Founder, Human Powered Future PLLC, Affiliated Faculty
University of Montana

What innovative sustainability ideas will make the most impact in the next 10-20 years? Developing the circular economy as described here.

What are your top three tips for green living?

My top 12 are in my latest book, “Zero Waste in the Last Best Place.”

Why is the U.S. so far behind other countries on sustainable transportation advancements like mass transit, including high-speed trains? What would it take to catch up?

In the ’70s, Nixon established the oil standard. Messing around with this could cause substantial harm to the U.S. dollar (USD), since it’s basically illegal to sell oil in any currency other than the USD. This is primarily why Sadam Hussein was assassinated and Iraq was invaded. It is going to take a very special techno-financial innovator to break this spell.

Methodology

First, we determined the factors (metrics) that are most relevant to the Most Sustainable Cities. We then assigned a weight to each factor based on its importance and grouped those factors into five categories: Policy, Sustainable Development, Pollution, Transportation, and Food Production. The categories, factors, and their weights are listed in the table below.

For each of the 200 biggest U.S. cities, we then gathered data on each factor from the sources listed below the table.

Finally, we calculated scores (out of 100 points) for each city to determine its rank in each factor, each category, and overall. A city’s Overall Score is the average of its scores across all factors and categories. The highest Overall Score ranked “Best” (No. 1) and the lowest “Worst” (No. 200).

Note: The “Worst” among individual factors may not be No. 200 due to ties.

Sources: American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, DSIRE, Global Green, Green Restaurant Association, Lawn Love, Local Governments for Sustainability, OpenTable, Other LawnStarter Studies, New Buildings Institute, Texas A&M Transportation Institute, TRIP, Trust for Public Land, U.S. Census Bureau, U.S. Department of Energy, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and WalkScore

Time Is Ticking: Why This Study Matters

The world is only seven years away from 2030, the year the United Nations hopes to achieve its Sustainable Development Goals

Unfortunately, the U.S. lags behind on green efforts. So far, only a handful of major cities in the U.S. have documented local reviews about their sustainable development progress. 

Thankfully, the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 will help empower the nation’s sustainability efforts with a $400 billion investment in decreasing emissions and increasing green technology. 

This study aims to highlight the regions that are leading the way in green development and conservation efforts. Even lawn care is going green these days, with more than 100 local governments enacting bans or limitations on the sale of gas-powered mowers, blowers, and trimmers.

Media Resources

Main Photo Credit: Shutterstock

Avatar

Sav Maive

Sav Maive is a writer and director based in San Antonio. Sav is a graduate of the University of Virginia and is a loving cat and plant mom.